"Avoid These Workplace Dogs", Minneapolis Star
Tribune, March 20, 2006
Two of my favorite sections of a
bookstore are career development (human capital) and dog breeds
(canine capital).
The human capital books are
written from the standpoint of either the job seeker or the
hiring manager. The dog books are aimed at the owner, given
dogs' literary limitations. (In fairness, dogs would probably
read self-improvement books if they were able, while cats
wouldn't want to be bothered.)
These dual interests have led me
to develop a canine-inspired hiring template that includes
workplace breeds to avoid -- whether as managers or employees.
To avoid angering dog lovers or corporation haters, please
consider these comparisons as metaphors, rather than comparisons
of people to dogs, or disparagement of particular breeds.
Employee breeds
1. Brilliant Border Collie. "I want the
smartest dog," you say. But do you own a flock of sheep? If so,
your border collie's fierce intelligence and hypnotic stare will
be well utilized. But if he spends his days lying around the
house, he is more likely to use that intelligence to excavate
the couch.
No organization seeks to hire
mediocrities, but workers' abilities and ambitions should
broadly match their roles. Brilliant or wildly ambitious
employees in a small job, with no path for advancement, will
often act in a disruptive fashion.
2. Obsessive Basset Hound. Basset
hounds never lose the scent and will stubbornly follow the trail
even if it leads to an old shoe.
The workplace equivalent is the
artistic professional, whether business analyst, programmer or
marketer, who obsesses over elegance in their craft to the
detriment of utility. Reliable sources tell me this is also an
occupational hazard for journalists.
3. Bored Borzoi. Borzoi are Russian
wolfhounds, bred for many centuries to hunt, and are happiest
when running all day. Some adapt well to being companions, while
others pine for their specialized purpose.
Many professionals have four to
seven years of specialized training. Some are flexible or
curious enough to do work unrelated to their field; others will
feel under-utilized and unfulfilled. Bottom line: boredom
results for the sight hound with nothing to chase, or the
actuary with nothing to count.
4. Tail Chaser. Not a specific breed,
but any dog with a neurotic obsession to chase its tail. Surely
it will catch it soon! But even the fastest tail chaser will
lose the race to a slower dog that runs in a straight line.
Some people have all sorts of
talents but are constantly distracted or are unable to get out
of their own way. These corporate tail chasers achieve a
fraction of what they are capable of.
Manager Breeds
1. Lone Wolf. Some breeds were not
cultivated to have an emotional connection with people, as their
job was to be an isolated herder, or even to serve as a food
source.
Similarly, avoid managers with
low "emotional IQ." They might have been effective as individual
contributors based on their functional skills. But if they lack
empathy, they are unlikely to manage or mentor people
effectively.
2. Wolf in Sheep's Clothing. The
Bedlington terrier looks remarkably like a lamb, but is actually
a snarly, aggressive terrier bred to hunt vermin in coal mines.
A boss or employee with
passive-aggressive or manic-depressive tendencies will make your
life miserable, however charming the exterior persona. "Cute but
vicious" is a toxic cocktail.
3. Inbred Blueblood. Some breeds have
been inbred to the point of no return. The resulting purebred is
classy and dumb, with a strong sense of entitlement. This Dumb
Chum will not be a very responsive companion.
Similarly, the CEO's Dumb Chum frat
brother will expect you to do the work and will take the credit
for it.
4. Killer Komondor. The komondor is a
Hungarian mastiff with a beautiful corded white coat. It is a
flock guardian that can kill a bear.
Question: Do you have a bear
infestation problem? If not, then a dog with millennia of
aggression in its genes might not be the perfect pet.
Executives who are terminally
abusive to those around them will eventually turn on you as
well. It might be in your interest to work for them if the job
is a great one, but skepticism and a thick skin are called for.