In the past 10 years, information technology has gone from
being one leg of the economy to being its very foundation.
Internet and wireless technologies, global outsourcing and
"hosted business models" have transformed the roles of
technology executives from exceptional to common.
Information technology is notorious for its pace of change, and
the past three years have been exceptionally volatile. Radical
change in major technology segments are leading to different
qualifications for hiring executives to run those businesses.
All require executives who can leverage technology to create
new products, increase revenue and lower costs. They need
executives with a long track record of building profitable
businesses, who can apply their past success to the new realities.
Consider the changes in each of these industry segments:
• Fortune 500. A new class of corporate executives is
evolving in the Fortune 500 who use the Internet to optimize
traditional business functions. These executives include: vice
president, supply chain; chief customer officer, chief information
officer; chief financial officer, information technology; vice
president, strategic sourcing, and vice president, performance
management. Leading organizations are trying to create a corporate
culture in which business and technology executives have the
skills and flexibility to go back and forth between both
functions.
Successful executives for these roles will tend to be
business-driven, not technology-driven change agents. The
challenge is that corporations are accustomed to assessing
executives in three dimensions -- functional, management and
industry expertise. Adding a fourth dimension -- technology --
complicates the selection process. Also, is the job designed as a
customer-driven role, sponsored by one of the top two executives
in the organization or as a staff function with no clear sponsor?
If the latter, it is destined to fail.
• Software vendors. The IT vendor world is
experiencing the biggest series of changes since the rise of
independent software companies in the early 1980s and the advent
of personal computers.
The software industry is in a deep funk for a variety of
reasons: the economic downturn; excess capacity of enterprise
software in corporate IT departments and tightening of corporate
IT budgets; software becoming a commodity (as hardware did before
it), and little profitability in the industry aside from Microsoft
and Oracle.
Looking forward, the software industry will have more in common
with a service bureau than the packaged software vendors of the
past 20 years. And technology executive roles will be more like
those of classic business executives.
Identifying executives who can adapt to and leverage these
changes in marketing, selling and delivering software
functionality is critical. A successful track record is the
starting point, but hiring an executive because of his or her past
success in the software industry without examining their fit for
the changing landscape can backfire.
• IT consulting firms. After a decade of incredible
growth sparked by corporations implementing enterprise software
applications such as SAP and Peoplesoft, and pursuing Internet
initiatives, consultancies now are challenged by the economic
downturn. Corporate customers are buying less, and asking for
higher value from consultants. Offshore outsourcing is driving
down margins.
Finding experienced, disciplined, creative executives who can
build and operate profitable consulting firms in the face of these
challenges is critical. They must be businesspeople first who can
diagnose a client's business and build solutions, neither pure
strategists nor software delivery executives.
• Outsourcers. Outsourcing is a rapidly growing
industry, from call centers to business-process outsourcing of
back-office functions. But outsourcers, too, are challenged by the
economic downturn, by decreasing margins due to offshore
competition and by growing customer expectations.
Profitably growing an outsourcing business requires innovative
executives who can both strategize and execute. They must design,
sell and negotiate engagements that simultaneously have high
customer return on investment and are profitable for the firm.
Seeking Lou Gerstner
Consider IBM's experience in hiring Lou Gerstner as CEO in
1993. IBM's market share and profitability were eroding due to its
difficulty in adjusting to the growth of PCs and UNIX
workstations. IBM chose Gerstner, its first CEO from outside the
company, and from outside the computer industry.
Why did IBM select Gerstner? Because it recognized that, above
all, the company needed a strategist to determine what customers
really wanted and a change agent to transform IBM's
engineering-oriented culture to a customer-driven culture. In this
light, Gerstner's track record as a McKinsey strategy consultant,
a turnaround specialist at Nabisco and a builder of
financial-service product lines at American Express were a great
fit.
Gerstner was, by most accounts, highly successful. He changed
IBM's culture to that of an eclectic technology services company.
IBM's market value rose from about $29 billion when he took over
in 1993 to $181 billion when he gave up his CEO title in March
2002.
Granted, the value of IBM's stock grew at a higher rate than
the company itself, or its profitability. But compared with the
dismal prospects of most other computing vendors, IBM stands out
as having made a successful transition from product vendor to
services provider.
Has your industry changed?
The key to hiring the right technology executive for your
business is to brainstorm and answer the tough questions as to
what has changed in your market, and critical factors for success:
What outcomes would you like the person to deliver in 18
months? Is it viable under current market, industry and
organizational conditions?
Do traditional job description and qualifications apply, or do
you need unconventional skills? Or, as technology becomes more
interlinked with operations, a classic business executive?
For those interested in more information on this topic, I wrote
white paper, "Hiring Senior Executives for Technology
Businesses in a Time of Great Change," available for free at http://www.opentechnologies.com/.